Modelling Speech and Speakers: Gadamer and Davidson on dialogue, agreement, and intelligible difference

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25180/lj.v24i1.280

Keywords:

Gadamer, Davidson, dialogue, agreement, alterity, other, intelligibility, cultural difference

Abstract

This paper examines Gadamer's and Davidson's dialogical models of interpretation. It shows them to be comparable, but importantly dissimilar with respect to the kind of agreement they require for communication to be possible. It is argued that this difference entails different concepts of alterity: they model not only how we talk, but implicitly who we can intelligibly talk to. Another important contribution of this paper is to uncover a distinction in Gadamer between two kinds of agreement missed so far by all commentators. The final section of this paper defends a second thesis, namely that the degree of agreement required by the models is proportional to the conceptual difference it can make intelligible. Hence, the extent of graspable cultural difference is not only an empirical matter, but is entailed by our choice of model.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Aristoteles. 2014. De interpretatione (Peri hermeneias). Edited by Hermann Weidemann. Berlin: De Gruyter.

Ball, Derek, and Brian Rabern, eds. 2018. The Science of Meaning: Essays on the Metatheory of Natural Language Semantics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Brandom, Robert. 1994. Making it Explicit. Reasoning, Representing and Discur-sive Commitment. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Braver, Lee. 2011. "Davidson's Reading of Gadamer: Triangulation, Conversation, and the Analytic-Continental Divide." In Malpas (ed.) 2011a. 149-166.

Davidson Donald. 1989. "James Joyce and Humpty Dumpty." In Davidson 2005. 143-157.

Davidson, Donald, and Kathrin Glüer. 1995. "Relations and Transitions. An Inter-view with Donald Davidson." Dialectica 49 (1): 75-86.

Davidson, Donald. 1967. "Truth and Meaning." In Davidson 1984. 17-36.

Davidson, Donald. 1973. "Radical Interpretation." In Davidson 1984. 125-140.

Davidson, Donald. 1974a. "Belief and the Basis of Meaning." In Davidson 1984. 141-154.

Davidson, Donald. 1974b. "On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme." In Davidson 1984. 183-198.

Davidson, Donald. 1975. "Thought and Talk." In Davidson 1984. 155-170.

Davidson, Donald. 1977. "The Method of Truth in Metaphysics." In Davidson 1984. 199-214.

Davidson, Donald. 1980. "Toward a Unified Theory of Meaning and Action." Grazer Philosophische Studien 11 (1): 1-12.

Davidson, Donald. 1982. "Communication and Convention." In Davidson 1984. 265-280.

Davidson, Donald. 1983. "A Coherence Theory of Truth and Knowledge." In Davidson 2001. 137-157.

Davidson, Donald. 1984. Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Davidson, Donald. 1984a. "Introduction." In Davidson 1984. xiii-xx.

Davidson, Donald. 1986. "A Nice Derangement of Epitaphs." In Davidson 2005. 89-107.

Davidson, Donald. 1990. "Meaning, Truth, and Evidence." In Davidson 2005. 47-62.

Davidson, Donald. 1991. "Three Varieties of Knowledge." In A. Phillips Griffiths (ed.). Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement 30: 153-166.

Davidson, Donald. 1992a. "The Socratic Concept of Truth." In Davidson 2005. 241-250.

Davidson, Donald. 1992b. "The Second Person." Midwest Studies in Philosophy 17 (1): 255-267.

Davidson, Donald. 1993. "Locating Literary Language." In Davidson 2005. 167-181.

Davidson, Donald. 1994a. "The Social Aspect of Language." In Davidson 2005. 109-125.

Davidson, Donald. 1994b. "Dialectic and Dialogue." In Davidson 2005. 251-259.

Davidson, Donald. 1997. "Gadamer and Plato's Philebus." In Davidson 2005. 261-275.

Davidson, Donald. 2001. Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Davidson, Donald. 2005. Truth, Language, and History. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Di Cesare, Donatella. 2007. "Das unendliche Gespräch. Sprache als Medium der hermeneutischen Erfahrung (GW 1, 387-441)." In Figal (ed.) 2007. 177-198.

Di Cesare, Donatella. 2016. "Understanding." In Niall Keane, and Chris Lawn (eds.). The Blackwell Companion to Hermeneutics. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell, 2016. 229-235.

Dostal, Robert J. 2022. Gadamer's Hermeneutics. Between Phenomenology and Di-alectic. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.

Dostal, Robert. 2011. "In Gadamer's Neighborhood." In Malpas 2011a. 167-190.

Figal, Günter. 2007. Hans-Georg Gadamer: Wahrheit und Methode. Klassiker Auslegen. Vol. 30. Berlin: Akademie Verlag.

Føllesdal, Dagfinn. 2011. "Foreword." In Malpas 2011a. ix-xiv.

Fultner, Barbara. 2011. "Incommensurability in Davidson and Gadamer." In Malpas 2011a. 219-240.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1960. "Die Natur der Sache und die Sprache der Dinge." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 66-76.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1966a. "Mensch und Sprache." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 146-154.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1966b. "Die Universalität des hermeneutischen Problems." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 219-231.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1967. "Rhetorik, Hermeneutik und Ideologiekritik. Metakritische Erörterungen zu "Wahrheit und Methode"." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 232-250.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1968. "Klassische und philosophische Hermeneutik." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 92-117.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1968. "Klassische und philosophische Hermeneutik." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 92-117.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1970a. "Sprache und Verstehen." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 184-198.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1972a. "Die Unfähigkeit zum Gespräch." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 207-215.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1972b. "Nachwort zur 3. Auflage." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 449-478.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1973. "Selbstdarstellung Hans-Georg Gadamer." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 479-508.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1976a. "Rhetorik und Hermeneutik." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 276-291.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1978. "Hermeneutik als theoretische und praktische Aufgabe." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 301-319.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1981a. "Stimme und Sprache." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 8. 258-270.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1981b. Reason in the Age of Science. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1985-1995. Gesammelte Werke, 10 vols. Tübingen: Mohr-Siebeck.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1985. Wahrheit und Methode. Grundzüge einer philosophischen Hermeneutik. In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 1.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1985a. "Zwischen Phänomenologie und Dialektik. Versuch einer Selbstkritik." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 2-23.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1985b. "Destruktion und Dekonstruktion." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2. 361-372.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1985c. "Grenzen der Sprache." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 8. 350-361.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1989. Truth and Method. Translation by Joel Weinsheimer and Donald G. Marshall. New York: Continuum.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1990. "Die Vielfalt der Sprachen und das Verstehen der Welt." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 8. 339-349.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1992. "Zur Phänomenologie von Ritual und Sprache." In Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 8. 400-440.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 1996. The Enigma of Health. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 2000a. "Boundaries of Language (1985)." Translation of Gadamer 1985c by Lawrence K. Schmidt. In Schmidt 2000. 9-18.

Gadamer, Hans-Georg. 2007. The Gadamer Reader: A Bouquet of the Later Writings. Edited and translated by Richard Palmer. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.

Gadamer, Hans-George. 1997. "Reflections on my Philosophical Journey." In Hahn (ed.) 1997. 3-63.

Glüer, Kathrin. 2013. "Convention and Meaning." In Lepore and Ludwig (eds.) 2013. 339-360.

Glüer, Kathrin. 2018. "Interpretation and the Interpreter: On the Role of the Interpreter in Davidsonian Foundational Semantics." In Ball and Rabern (eds.) 2018. 226-252.

Griffiths, Phillips A. 1992. A. J. Ayer: Memorial Essays. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hahn, Lewis Edwin, ed. 1997. The Philosophy of Hans-Georg Gadamer. The Li-brary of Living Philosophers. Vol. 24. Chicago: Open Court.

Kapsch, Edda. 2007. Verstehen des Anderen. Fremdverstehen im Anschluss an Husserl, Gadamer und Derrida. Berlin: Parodos.

Kertscher, Jens. 2002. "'We Understand Differently, If We Understand at All': Gadamer's Ontology of Language Reconsidered." In Malpas, Arnswald, and Kertscher (eds.) 2002. 135-156.

Kogge, Werner. 2001. Verstehen und Fremdheit in der philosophischen Hermeneu-tik. Heidegger und Gadamer. Zürich: Hildesheim.

Lepore, Ernest, and Kirk Ludwig, eds. 2013. A companion to Donald Davidson. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell.

Lynch, Greg. 2014. "Does Conversation Need Shared Language? Davidson and Gadamer on Communicative Understanding." The Southern Journal of Philosophy 52 (3): 359-381.

Malpas, Jeff, and Santiago Zabala, eds. 2010. Consequences of Hermeneutics: Fifty Years After Gadamer's Truth and Method. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.

Malpas, Jeff, ed. 2011a. Dialogues with Davidson. Acting, Interpreting, Under-standing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Malpas, Jeff, Ulrich Arnswald, and Jens Kertscher, eds. 2002. Gadamer's Century. Essays in Honor of Hans-Georg Gadamer. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Malpas, Jeff. 1990. "Locating Interpretation: The Topography of Understanding in Heidegger and Davidson." Philosophical Topics: 27 (2): 129-148.

Malpas, Jeff. 2002. "Gadamer, Davidson, and the Ground of Understanding." In Malpas, Arnswald, and Kertscher (eds.) 2002. 195-215.

Malpas, Jeff. 2010. "The Origin of Understanding: Event, Place, Truth." In Malpas and Zabala 2010. 261-280.

Malpas, Jeff. 2011b. "What Is Common to All: Davidson on Agreement and Un-derstanding." In Malpas 2011a. 259-280.

McDowell, John. 2002. "Gadamer and Davidson on Understanding and Relativism." In Malpas, Arnswald, and Kertscher (eds.) 2002. 173-194.

Myers, Robert H., and Claudine Verheggen. 2016. Donald Davidson's Triangulation Argument: A Philosophical Inquiry. New York and London: Routledge.

Schleiermacher, Friedrich. 1998. Hermeneutics and Criticism. And Other Writings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Schmidt, Lawrence K. 2000. Language and Linguisticality in Gadamer's Hermeneutics. Lanham, Boulder, New York, Oxford: Lexington Books.

Sokolowski, Robert. 1997. "Gadamer's Theory of Hermeneutics." In Hahn (ed.) 1997. 223-235.

Vessey, David. 2011. "Davidson, Gadamer, Incommensurability, and the Third Dogma of Empiricism." In Malpas 2011a. 241-258.

Vessey, David. 2012. "Gadamer and Davidson on Language and Thought." Philosophy Compass 7 (1): 33-42.

Downloads

Published

03.09.2022

How to Cite

Lazurca, V. (2022). Modelling Speech and Speakers: Gadamer and Davidson on dialogue, agreement, and intelligible difference. Labyrinth, 24(1), 67–95. https://doi.org/10.25180/lj.v24i1.280